On January 1, 2021, the newly-passed Music Modernization Act (MMA) took
effect. The law was initially launched to take into account new
technology and address how it affects the sale of music creations.
However, text in the law leaves room for potential corruption in the way
music creators may (or may not) be paid.
Specifically, an arm of the MMA -- the Mechanical Royalty
Collective (MLC) -- is responsible for paying music creators mechanical
royalties they are due. Among other things, mechanicals apply to many
types of streaming music (the most-used method of listening to music
these days).
One of the potential problem with the MLC paying out mechanical
royalties lays in the database they will use to make payouts. The
database with which the MLC will begin is one belonging to the Harry Fox
Agency (HFA).
The database is known to be incomplete in the sense that many
creators move without the database being updated. Also heirs of creators
who have died often don't know how to keep information updated. The
result has been that royalties due to creators/heirs often aren't paid
out. Instead, the royalties are held in accounts until the correct
people can be found and paid.
This is where another potential problem arises with the MLC. Rather than
being required to make honest efforts to find these creators/heirs, the
MLC will be allowed (after a time period) to take the royalties owed to
unfound creators/heirs and split them up, on a market-share basis, to
the big-money music interests that influenced the law to start. These
are groups like the major streaming companies, major publishers and
others. Essentially, the MLC can allow already-wealthy, big-monied music
interests to profit from money owed to smaller creators and heirs
simply by not seeking them out. Currently there is more than a billion
dollars at stake that hasn't been paid out, so the stakes are high.
The Songwriters Guild of America urges all creators to educate
themselves about the MLC. If music creators and their heirs hope to be
paid what they're owed they must: